How Do I Know If My Website Is Losing Me Customers?

What are the warning signs a website is costing me customers?

A losing website rarely announces itself. Nobody emails you to say the site talked them out of calling. They just leave, quietly, and become someone else's customer. So you have to read the indirect signs, and most owners have seen several without connecting them.

• New customers always say a friend sent them, never the website.
• Regulars are surprised to learn you offer something that has been on your site for years.
• You search for your service and your town, and your site is nowhere on the first page.
• Your contact form mostly collects spam, when it collects anything.
• The site takes more than a few seconds to load on your own phone, on cellular data.
• You have to pinch and zoom to read your own pages on a phone.
• The footer still shows a copyright year from two or three years ago.

One of these alone is not proof. Two or three together usually mean the site is turning people away before you ever hear from them. The good news: every item on this list is checkable tonight, without spending a dollar or talking to a salesperson.

What can I check tonight, for free, in under an hour?

Grab your phone and a timer. These five checks take less than an hour combined, and they will tell you more than most paid audits.

• The phone test. Open your site on your own phone, on cellular data, not wifi. Count the seconds until you can read the page and tap something. Most of your visitors are on phones, and they will not wait long.
• The stranger search. Open a private browsing window and search the way a customer would: your service plus your town, not your business name. If you are not on the first page, people who need exactly what you sell cannot see you. That is a visibility problem, and it is one of the most common we find.
• The five-second test. Show your homepage to someone who does not know your business, for five seconds, then take it away. Ask what the business does and what they were supposed to do next. If they cannot answer both, your first screen is failing. What that screen should say is its own topic, and we cover it separately.
• The contact-yourself test. Fill out your own form. Call the number listed on your site. Note how hard each one was to find and what happens afterward. If the confirmation lands in spam, or the number takes three taps to reach, your customers hit the same wall.
• The numbers check. If you have Google Analytics or Search Console, compare monthly visitors to monthly inquiries. If you have no analytics at all, that is itself a finding: you have been flying blind, and installing a free counter is step one.

Write down what you find as you go. A messy list beats a vague worry, and it becomes your punch list for everything that follows.

Do free website graders actually tell you anything useful?

Yes, for the mechanical problems. A grader measures things you cannot eyeball: how fast your pages load, whether they fit a phone screen, whether search engines can read them, and whether a visitor can find a way to contact you without hunting. Google's PageSpeed Insights, for example, is free and will score your speed in about a minute.

We built one too. The Tarvis AI grader is free: paste your web address at /apps/scan/?src=answers, wait about 60 seconds, and you get a letter grade plus a plain-English list of the money leaks it found. To prove the tool is honest, we ran it on our own site first and published the result, a C minus, along with every fix we had to make, at /blog/we-graded-ourselves/. If a grading tool never embarrasses its own maker, be suspicious of it.

Here is what no grader can judge: whether your prices make sense, whether your photos build trust, whether your offer is something people actually want. A scan finds the mechanical problems fast. The judgment calls are still yours to make.

When is it worth paying someone to fix it?

Only after you have run the free checks, and only for the problems you cannot fix yourself. Sort everything you found into two piles.

• Fix it yourself tonight: put your phone number at the top of every page, cut your contact form down to three fields, rewrite your headline so it says what you do and where. These are ordinary edits in Squarespace, Wix, WordPress, or whatever builder you use.
• Get help: slow load times, pages that break on phones, a site that search engines cannot read. These usually need technical hands, and they are worth paying for because they block everything else.

Think of your website as plumbing for money. Visitors flow in, customers should flow out, and when a pipe leaks you do not tear the house down. You patch that pipe. Most small business sites do not need a full rebuild; they need two or three specific leaks patched. If you want ours, Tarvis fixes everything the scan finds for 490 dollars flat, done in 72 hours. But run the free checks first, whether or not you ever hire anyone. And never pay someone who will not show you exactly what is broken before quoting the fix.

Questions people also ask